Existing Annuity Review

Before You Replace an Annuity, Understand What You Already Own.

An existing annuity may contain guarantees, income benefits, surrender provisions, rates, riders, or contract features that should be understood before considering a change.

Annuity HQ can help organize and review the key features of your current contract so you can better understand what it is designed to do, what access you have to your money, what benefits may already exist, and which tradeoffs should be considered before comparing another option.

Request an Annuity Review Learn About Annuities
Understand First Know the current guarantees, benefits, restrictions, and values before comparing another contract.
Compare Carefully Evaluate the existing contract and any proposed alternative using the same retirement objective.
Replace Only When Appropriate A new contract should provide enough meaningful benefit to justify any new surrender period, costs, or lost features.
Annuity contracts vary by insurer, state, issue age, contract type, rider, and other factors. A replacement can involve surrender charges, new surrender periods, tax consequences, loss of guarantees or benefits, and other considerations. Guarantees are subject to the terms of the contract and the claims-paying ability of the issuing insurer.
Possible Review Outcomes

Keep It, Improve the Strategy, or Consider a Replacement?

A useful annuity review does not begin with the assumption that your current contract should be replaced. The purpose is to understand what you own and determine which course of action best fits the retirement objective.

OUTCOME 01

Keep the Existing Contract

Sometimes the contract already does its job well and the most appropriate decision is to leave it in place.

  • Attractive existing guarantees
  • Valuable income benefits
  • Little or no surrender period remaining
  • Competitive current crediting options
  • Useful liquidity provisions
  • No compelling reason to reset the contract
Possible conclusion The current annuity may still be appropriate for the job it was intended to perform.
OUTCOME 02

Improve How It Fits the Plan

The contract itself may remain appropriate, while the broader retirement strategy around it can be improved.

  • Change how other assets are allocated
  • Reconsider withdrawal sequencing
  • Coordinate income timing
  • Review beneficiary designations
  • Evaluate tax implications
  • Use contract features more effectively
Possible conclusion The annuity stays, but the surrounding retirement strategy changes.
OUTCOME 03

Consider a Replacement

A replacement may deserve consideration when a meaningful planning benefit outweighs the costs and tradeoffs of moving.

  • Retirement objectives have changed
  • Needed income features are unavailable
  • Current contract costs are no longer justified
  • Liquidity needs are not being met
  • Materially different benefits are available
  • The replacement improves the overall plan
Possible conclusion A replacement may be worth evaluating, but only after the old and new contracts are compared carefully.
The Replacement Test

A New Contract Should Earn Its Place.

Replacing an annuity can restart surrender periods, change guarantees, alter income benefits, create new restrictions, and potentially affect taxes or other financial planning decisions.

That means a new annuity should not be considered simply because it has a larger headline rate, bonus, or illustrated benefit.

The new contract should provide a meaningful improvement for the specific retirement objective after the important costs, restrictions, and lost benefits are considered.

Before Replacing, Compare:

1
Current surrender value vs. new starting value

Understand any amount that may be lost or unavailable during the transition.

2
Existing guarantees vs. new guarantees

Identify contractual benefits that would be surrendered or changed.

3
Remaining surrender period vs. new surrender period

Consider whether moving resets the clock on access to the money.

4
Income benefits and rider provisions

Compare how income is calculated, when it can begin, and any fees or limitations.

5
Liquidity and withdrawal provisions

Determine how much access is available under both contracts.

6
The actual retirement objective

The replacement should solve a meaningful planning problem, not simply create a different contract.

Annuity replacements are subject to suitability requirements and may involve surrender charges, new surrender periods, loss of existing guarantees or benefits, changes in fees, and tax considerations. Contract terms should be reviewed carefully before making a change. Guarantees are subject to the claims-paying ability of the issuing insurer.
Preparing for Your Review

A Better Review Starts With the Actual Contract.

Annuities can look similar on the surface while containing very different guarantees, income features, withdrawal rules, fees, crediting methods, and surrender provisions. The contract documents help us understand what you actually own.

Helpful Documents

What to Gather

You may not need every document below, but these items can make an existing annuity review more complete.

Most Recent Annuity Statement Helps identify current account value, surrender value, contract anniversary, and current allocations.
Original Contract or Policy Pages Shows contractual guarantees, surrender provisions, withdrawal rules, and other important terms.
Income Rider Information Useful when the annuity includes a lifetime income benefit, withdrawal base, roll-up, or rider fee.
Current Crediting Strategy Information May include fixed rates, index choices, caps, participation rates, spreads, or renewal information.
Original Illustration, If Available Can help compare what was originally illustrated with the contract's current status and actual provisions.
Beneficiary & Ownership Information Helps identify current ownership structure and beneficiary designations when relevant.
Do not send passwords, account login credentials, full Social Security numbers, or other unnecessary sensitive information through a general website form.
STEP 01

Identify the Contract

Determine the insurer, product, issue date, contract type, current value, and the original reason the annuity was purchased.

STEP 02

Understand the Benefits

Review guarantees, income provisions, death benefits, crediting options, riders, and other features that may have value today.

STEP 03

Identify the Restrictions

Examine surrender charges, withdrawal limitations, rider requirements, fees, liquidity provisions, and other contract restrictions.

STEP 04

Define Its Current Job

Determine whether the annuity is intended primarily for income, principal protection, accumulation, liquidity, legacy, or another retirement objective.

STEP 05

Compare Alternatives

If another strategy is considered, compare both options using the same retirement objective rather than comparing isolated rates or features.

STEP 06

Evaluate the Tradeoffs

Consider surrender charges, lost benefits, new restrictions, increased risk, tax implications, liquidity, and whether a proposed change meaningfully improves the retirement plan.

You Do Not Need to Know Whether Your Annuity Is “Good” or “Bad.”

That is what the review is designed to help determine. Begin with the contract, the retirement objective, and the questions you have. From there, the benefits and tradeoffs can be evaluated in context.

The Goal Understand what you own well enough to make an informed decision about keeping it, using it differently, or comparing another option.
Annuity contracts and replacement rules vary by insurer, product, state, ownership, tax status, and individual circumstances. A replacement may involve surrender charges, new surrender periods, loss of existing guarantees or benefits, increased risk, changes in fees, and tax considerations. Guarantees are subject to contract terms and the claims-paying ability of the issuing insurer.
Understand Before You Change

Your Existing Annuity May Be Better — or Worse — Than You Think.

The only reliable way to know is to look at the actual contract, current values, remaining surrender period, income benefits, guarantees, liquidity provisions, fees, and the retirement job the annuity is supposed to perform.

A review does not obligate you to replace anything. In some cases, the appropriate conclusion may be to keep the existing contract. In others, there may be a reason to use it differently or compare another option.

Request My Annuity Review Use the Annuity Comparison Tool
Annuity contracts and replacement requirements vary by insurer, product, state, ownership, tax status, and individual circumstances. Replacements may involve surrender charges, new surrender periods, loss of existing guarantees or benefits, increased risk, changes in fees, and tax considerations. Guarantees are subject to contract terms and the claims-paying ability of the issuing insurer.